Top 50 Auto Insurance Company Claim Guides
Compare NAIC complaint benchmarks (1.00 = national median), adjuster negotiation patterns, and diminished value policies across 50 major US auto insurers.
- State Farm (National Major) — 0.63 NAIC Index
- Progressive (National Major) — 0.84 NAIC Index
- GEICO (National Major) — 0.72 NAIC Index
- Allstate (National Major) — 0.96 NAIC Index
- USAA (National Major) — 0.58 NAIC Index
- Liberty Mutual (National Major) — 0.89 NAIC Index
- Farmers Insurance (National Major) — 0.91 NAIC Index
- Travelers (National Major) — 0.76 NAIC Index
- American Family (National Major) — 0.82 NAIC Index
- Nationwide (National Major) — 0.85 NAIC Index
- Auto-Owners Insurance (Regional Leader) — 0.54 NAIC Index
- Erie Insurance (Regional Leader) — 0.49 NAIC Index
- AAA (Auto Club / CSAA / ACG) (Regional Leader) — 0.67 NAIC Index
- Chubb (Specialty) — 0.45 NAIC Index
- The Hartford (National Major) — 0.74 NAIC Index
- Mercury Insurance (Regional Leader) — 1.08 NAIC Index
- Kemper Auto (Non-Standard / High-Risk) — 1.42 NAIC Index
- Amica Mutual (Regional Leader) — 0.38 NAIC Index
- Safeco (Regional Leader) — 0.87 NAIC Index
- National General (Non-Standard / High-Risk) — 1.29 NAIC Index
- Sentry Insurance (Specialty) — 0.92 NAIC Index
- Dairyland Auto (Non-Standard / High-Risk) — 1.18 NAIC Index
- The General (Non-Standard / High-Risk) — 1.35 NAIC Index
- Direct Auto Insurance (Non-Standard / High-Risk) — 1.31 NAIC Index
- Bristol West (Non-Standard / High-Risk) — 1.24 NAIC Index
- Root Insurance (Direct / Digital) — 1.48 NAIC Index
- Lemonade Car (Direct / Digital) — 1.38 NAIC Index
- Esurance (Direct / Digital) — 0.99 NAIC Index
- COUNTRY Financial (Regional Leader) — 0.57 NAIC Index
- The Hanover (Regional Leader) — 0.78 NAIC Index
- Cincinnati Insurance (Regional Leader) — 0.56 NAIC Index
- Shelter Insurance (Regional Leader) — 0.64 NAIC Index
- NJM Insurance Group (Regional Leader) — 0.41 NAIC Index
- Plymouth Rock Assurance (Regional Leader) — 0.88 NAIC Index
- MAPFRE Insurance (Commerce) (Regional Leader) — 0.94 NAIC Index
- CSAA Insurance Group (Regional Leader) — 0.69 NAIC Index
- Texas Farm Bureau (Regional Leader) — 0.59 NAIC Index
- Kentucky Farm Bureau (Regional Leader) — 0.61 NAIC Index
- Farm Bureau of Tennessee (Regional Leader) — 0.55 NAIC Index
- Farm Bureau Financial Services (Regional Leader) — 0.66 NAIC Index
- Alfa Insurance (Regional Leader) — 0.62 NAIC Index
- Grange Insurance (Regional Leader) — 0.77 NAIC Index
- Selective Insurance (Regional Leader) — 0.79 NAIC Index
- Westfield Insurance (Regional Leader) — 0.71 NAIC Index
- Foremost Insurance (Specialty) — 0.98 NAIC Index
- Hagerty (Specialty) — 0.34 NAIC Index
- Clearcover (Direct / Digital) — 1.22 NAIC Index
- Elephant Insurance (Direct / Digital) — 1.15 NAIC Index
- GAINSCO Auto Insurance (Non-Standard / High-Risk) — 1.46 NAIC Index
- Acceptance Insurance (Non-Standard / High-Risk) — 1.52 NAIC Index